path: Home / Australia The Australian Press on Individual Episodes
- These Were Collected by L.M. & Organized by Natalie G.
- REVIEWS FOR "HE SHALL, FROM TIME TO TIME"
Date: 22nd January, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: TV Previews
Author: Greg Hassall
- The West Wing; Nine, 9.30pm
Preparations for the annual State of the Union address are complicated by the President's mysterious illness, tortuous negotiations with poll-wary Democrats, a flare-up on the India-Pakistan border and the lid finally coming off Leo's past addiction to Valium and alcohol. All this and much more is skilfully jammed into the hour, unfolding in quick-fire exchanges as the characters rush through corridors and offices like studies in perpetual motion. This is a really entertaining
drama, treating its viewers as politically savvy adults. Its only real weakness is a tendency towards sentimentality, something few American dramas seem to be able to avoid. There are potential clouds on the horizon, however. As the Republicans reclaim the White House, there soon will be a serious dislocation between drama and reality, a problem for a show that draws so much of its material from real-life events. Unencumbered by the requirements of the democratic process,
it's hard to see the show's producers radically overhauling a ratings success, but they may not have a choice. In a way, it's a pity the show's not on its last legs an election loss for President Bartlett would be the perfect way to wind up the series.
- REVIEW FOR "TAKE OUT THE TRASH DAY"
Date: 29th January, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: TV Previews
Author: Tony Davis
- The West Wing; Nine, 9.30pm It's "Take out the Trash'' day on this classy US political drama. The term relates to the way the President's press machine bundles all the unfavourable stories together and releases them as a job lot on a Friday. That way they won't all get a run and, anyway, fewer people are likely to read
them at the weekend. The West Wing is going from strength to strength, sentimentality and unlikely romantic subplots notwithstanding. Last week we saw an ample demonstration of how many compromises are involved in finalising a State of the Union address. Those who saw it never need to wonder again why political speeches never say anything. This week President Martin Sheen is spruiking a hate-crimes bill, but suppressing a sex-education report that raises issues he does not want to
deal with and uses words he doesn't want to say in public. In one exchange this week, White House staffers use the term ``sticky wicket''; it's a surprise, particularly since Chambers Idioms confirms it as solely a cricketing term. Maybe it's payback for non-baseball countries using ``out of left field''.
- REVIEWS FOR "20 HOURS IN LA"
Date: 20th February, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: A Little Presidential Babe-watching Veers Towards The Awful Truth, While The Plod's Been Nicked
Author: Doug Anderson
- The West Wing; 9.30pm, 9: Jeb Bartlett and his staff tool into Hollywood for a fundraiser. This junket is not without its attractions as a covey of strapping starlet’s rush to brush up against the presidential trouser-leg for photo opportunities. But there are dangers a'plenty, too, as an interlude with dentally magnificent
Baywatch hero Mitch Buchannon (David Hasselhoff), demonstrates.
- REVIEWS FOR "WHITE HOUSE PRO-AM"
Date: 27th February, 2001
Publication: The Age
Headline: Patients A Virtue? Nope
Author: Jonathan Green
- Diverted by the likes of The West Wing (Nine, 9.30pm), and the enticing warmth
of its First-World play politics. Tonight, the Federal chairman dies, the First
Lady cruises 20 points up in the polls and the vote on a vital trade bill falters.
Rob Lowe looks increasingly like a youthful Larry Hagman, and we ask, why don't
these guys ever take off their jackets? Love it.
- REVIEWS FOR "SIX MEETINGS BEFORE LUNCH"
Date: 6th March, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: Yuppie Revolt Puts The Slavedrivers In The Spotlight, While A Kubrickian Homer Goes Into Orbit
Author: Doug Anderson
- The West Wing; 9.30pm, 9:
Staff at the White House are rapt by the confirmation of Robert Mendoza as a
justice of the US Supreme Court. Josh has a meeting with Jeff Breckenridge,
a civil rights lawyer from Georgia, who has nominated for Assistant Attorney-General
for Civil Rights. Meanwhile, the son of a prominent Democrat supporter (and
fundraiser) is arrested for distributing drugs at a party attended by Zoey,
and media hacks are soon on the scene, sniffing around hercollege dorm. Secret
Service agent Gina ushers them out but discovers Zoey has given the press a
cock-and-bull version of events. This will never do. Spindoctoring is always
preferable to a spontaneous fib. A large panda enters stage left.
- REVIEWS FOR "LET BARTLET BE BARTLET"
Date: 12th March, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: TV Previews
Author: Greg Hassall
- The West Wing; Nine, 9.30pm
It's a bad day at the office all round. A memo Mandy wrote when she worked briefly
for a Republican has surfaced, highlighting the weaknesses of the Bartlet administration.
As unpalatable as it is for the rest of the White House staff, it underscores
a growing sense the administration has lost its way, obsessed with winning another
term rather than achieving anything worthwhile during this one. The West Wing
is one of the most enjoyable shows to come out of the US in years. Despite such
high-profile stars as Martin Sheen and Rob Lowe, the cast has a genuine ensemble
feel to it. And the scripts are just fantastic so good, in fact, that you can
forgive the odd moment of hand-on-heart patriotism and blow-torch sentimentality.
Although it's early in the year, we're almost at the end of the first series
and it is unclear at this stage whether Nine will go straight into next season's
episodes or hold the show back until the next non-ratings period. The show's
ratings have been steady, but unspectacular, and certainly won't guarantee it
a place in prime time. If it does disappear it will be sorely missed.
- Date: 13th March, 2001
Publication: The West Australian
Headline: Wake Up, Mr President
Author: Mark Naglazas
- THERE'S a boilover in tonight's The West Wing (Nine, 9.30) with the president's
staff scrambling to track down a memo in which Mandy, in her former role as
adviser to a political rival, outlined the weaknesses of the Bartlett administration.
While everyone is furious with Mandy for losing such a potentially damaging
document President Bartlett regards it as a wake-up call - a devastatingly accurate
summary of the failure of his administration to achieve anything in its first
year. It also triggers one of the most compelling confrontations yet in this
magnificent series, with Leo McGarry and the President blaming each other for
pushing the Bartlett administration into the blandly ineffectual middle.
Their conclusion - and it is deliciously ominous - is they've been too concerned
with Bartlett being a two-term president , of kowtowing to powerful right-wing
forces and special interest groups. Starting right away - or next Tuesday, at
least - President Bartlett and his staff will take the bull by the horns and
put their ideals into practice. I'll be watching and, hopefully, so will the
already beleaguered Geoff Gallop.
- REVIEWS FOR "MANDATORY MINIMUMS" & "LIES, DAMN LIES & STATISTICS"
Date: 16th March, 2001
Publication: Newcastle Herald
Headline: Channelsurf: The TV Week
Episode: Mandatory Minimums; Lies, Damn Lies & Statistics
- WEEK'S BEST: The West Wing
9.30pm Tuesday, PRESIDENT Bartlet and the rest of the White House over-achievers
earn this week's top billing because we get a whole two hours worth on Tuesday
night! Fans will be anxious to learn about the cliffhanger episode coming up
Tuesday-week but they're just going to have to wait because I'm not telling.
But I bet you didn't know Toby had an astronaut brother? As I said, over-achievers.
Anyway in the first of the two episodes to be screened back-to-back on Tuesday,
Toby meets with his congresswoman ex-wife to discuss mandatory minimum jail
sentences (what a painful family) and in the second episode, 'CJ had something
to prove'. After doing 'The Jackal' a couple of week ago, CJ's has nothing left
to prove in my book.
- REVIEWS FOR "WHAT KIND OF DAY HAS IT BEEN?"
Date: 27th March, 2001
Publication: Illawarra Mercury
Headline: TELEVISION
Author: Denise Everton
Episode: What Kind Of Day Has It Been?
- TELEVISION - THE WEST WING; WIN, 9.30PM
There's a whisper - a very, very faint whisper - that perhaps we won't have
to wait as long as expected to discover what happens after tonight's cliffhanger
finale of this brilliant US drama.
By far the best thing on television at the moment, The West Wing hosts an explosive
season finale in tonight's timeslot but just as we were bemoaning the loss of
A-class drama from our screens, a hint of hope has been unveiled. Perhaps the
show will follow in the footsteps of WIN Television's surprise hit family drama
Judging Amy and run immediately into the second season. Please, oh please ...
They can't leave us wondering who, if anyone, gets shot in an assassination
attempt during a presidential town hall meeting with the public. With the president,
his daughter Zoey (the subject of some daunting hate mail in recent episodes)
and most of his senior staff members in attendance, anything could happen. In
comparison to most episodes, this one is played at half pace, the frantic conversations
and brief mid-corridor strategy meetings replaced with a more personal agenda.
The aim is to build steadily to the moment when shooters open fire on a crowd
of people greeting the president following his Q&A session. It's superbly done
with moments of drama offset by humorous interludes and more than a little emotion.
It's impossible not to enjoy this show.
- Date: 26th March, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: TV Previews
Author: Robin Oliver
- The West Wing; Nine, 9.30pm
A last salute to the romanticised and therefore most acceptable political set-up
on the planet. President Josiah Bartlet (Martin Sheen) rules the White House
as a Nobel laureate we tend to forget that a compassionate Democrat, well read,
charming and when he needs to be, sharp-tongued with political mischief-makers.
A frantic day culminates in a town hall-style meeting with students in Virginia.
There are amusing moments, though early emphasis on the security guards prepares
viewers for the unresolved finale, but not for the fact that it sails over the
top, totally out of character. Creator and episode writer Aaron Sorkin admitted
the problem but resolved it in style at the start of the second set. We won't
have to wait. Series two resumes next Tuesday (April 12), but in a new 10.30pm
timeslot.
- REVIEWS FOR "IN THE SHADOW OF TWO GUNMEN II"
Date: 10th April, 2001
Publication: The Age
Headline: TV's Lore Of Averages
Author: Jonathan Green
- And this will take us tidily to the second episode of this new series of The
West Wing, in which we find President Bartlet still in hospital, but recovering,
and Josh fighting for his life through his sixth hour of extensive surgery.
It is the morning after the shooting of the night before and questions hang
heavy in the sombre air: who was in charge while the president was under anaesthetic;
did the secret service slip up; was POTUS really the target? This last is a
mystery answerable only by the members of West Virginia White Pride, one of
whom is arrested early in tonight's proceedings by such an impressive assembly
of police might that the US Seventh Fleet, Air Force One and Batman could have
joined in the collar and been invisible in the rush of law enforcers and hardware.
The president has been shot, and no one is taking any chances. While we wait
on Josh's recovery, the script backtracks to the moments three years earlier
when Josh, Sam, C.J. and Donna were recruited to the Bartlet campaign. Exciting
times as we roll from New Hampshire through a superbly handled string of primaries
to an acceptance speech in Los Angeles.
- Date: 10th April, 2001
Publication: The West Australian
Headline: Up Close In The White House
Author: Mark Naglazas
- IF I had any complaints about The West Wing's sizzling first season it is that
it tended be all work and no play - all politics and very little emphasis on
the personal. Curiously, this shying away from private lives does not chime
with the reality of the Clinton White House (the show's obvious model) in which
dozens of employees met and married.
Although there's no bedroom action on the immediate horizon of The West Wing,
the explosive finale of season one and last week's wrenching premiere of season
two, has taken us deep into the hearts of the president and his staff, lifting
the show to another level of excellence. This new-found emotional depth continues
tonight as Josh fights for his life after being hit during the attempt on the
president's life, a shattering event that has triggered a series of flashbacks
in which the staffers recall how they became involved in the Bartlet campaign.
Sadly, Nine has shifted the modestly rating show to the 10.30pm timeslot. But
this is a minor inconvenience for keeping President Bartlet and his smart, passionate,
hard-working staff in office.
- REVIEWS FOR "IN THIS WHITE HOUSE"
Date: 23rd April, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: TV Previews
Author: Robin Oliver
- Nine, 10.30pm
After last week's muddled story in which President Bartlet's team fussed over
Josh Lyman, still recovering from his bullet wound in the chest, and Bartlet,
injured in the same incident, allowed his political shrewdness to wander from
the straight and narrow, this fine series is back on track with solid and political
issues nicely woven into the ongoing drama. Josh (Bradley Whitford) and Bartlet
(Martin Sheen) are now fully restored to health and the President gives a radio
talk-back presenter he dislikes a splendid roasting not to be missed after she
fails to get to her feet when he appears at an official reception. Much hangs
on White House reactions when the confident Sam (Rob Lowe) is savaged by a fast-talking
Republican lawyer, Ainsley Hayes (Emily Procter), during a TV debate. Her dilemma
is now woven into a powerful story involving the president of a poverty-stricken
African country ravaged by AIDS. A compelling episode
- REVIEW FOR "AND IT'S SURELY TO THEIR CREDIT"
Date: 1st May, 2001
Publication: The Age
Headline: The Sound Of A Toaster Popping
Author: Jonathan Green
- The West Wing (Nine, 10.30pm) is routinely superb, a highlight being the beefy
presence of John Larroquette as senior White House counsel, a role he shares
with a cricket bat and several Gilbert and Sullivan highlights. No really.
- REVIEW FOR "THE LAME DUCK CONGRESS"
Date: 8th May, 2001
Publication: The Age
Headline: Behold, The Yank And File
Author: Jonathan Green
- The West Wing (Nine, 10.30pm) also recovers from an unsettling trend of recent
weeks that has seen television's greatest work since Chaucer toy disturbingly
with character driven narrative. This evening, we note a comforting return to
firmly political plotting, with Bartlet contemplating the recall of a lame duck
Congress left theoretically impotent by recent midterm elections, but still
holding perhaps his best chance of seeing a weapons test treaty ratified. Now
that's more like it.
- REVIEW FOR "SHIBBOLETH"
Date: 29th May, 2001
Publication: The Age
Headline: Life Without TV? Chaos!
Author: Jonathan Green
- "MRS Lanningham, I need to speak to the Governor of California.'' They're back!
If last week's unexpected soiree with Laurie Oakes proved an inadequate substitute,
if the intricacies of Australian fiscal policy left you wanting something a
little bit more First World, then good news: The West Wing returns (Nine, 10.30pm)
to enliven the late evening.
Meanwhile, back at the White House, CJ is attempting to choose the most photogenic
of two turkeys for the President's annual Thanksgiving turkey pardon. Two things
here: these people are Democrats, so no turkeys will die; and it's at moments
like these that we gain a fuller appreciation of just what it is that series
creator Aaron Sorkin gets from his well-publicised fondness for psychotropic
fungus. This is an episode that also reintroduces the loony religious right
for another paddling, this time over school prayer, and has the president set
Chinese asylum seekers free to wander the hinterland of northern California.
Then there's the business of the Paul Revere carving knife. Have another mushroom,
Aaron.
- Date: 28th May, 2001;
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline:TV Previews
Author: Greg Hassall
- Can You Live Without?:
Television: The West Wing Nine, 10.30pm
Americans really are suckers for that God and country stuff. The West Wing is
one of the more sophisticated dramas of recent years, but sharp observation
too often gives way to misty-eyed patriotism. Tonight, Laura Innes (who plays
Dr Kerry Weaver on E.R.) directs that American staple, the Thanksgiving episode.
Every US drama seems to have one, invariably drowning in schmaltz. Here C.J.
must choose which of two turkeys is the most photogenic, Leo fights his sister's
nomination for a national education post and President Bartlet wonders what
to do with a boatload of Chinese Christians seeking religious asylum. There
are plenty of good moments, and it's still streets ahead of most TV drama, but
this is one The West Wing episode you can afford to miss.
-
REVIEW FOR "GALILEO"
Date: 4th June, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline:TV Previews
Author: Bernard Zuel
- The West Wing Nine, 10.30pm
If The West Wing was a cable show, like The Sopranos or Larry Sanders, we would
get plenty of grit and ugliness to balance or even outweigh the idealism. It's
not going to happen on a network show, so sentiment is always there (from that
stirring theme music to a junior aide lecturing superiors on commonsense, and
not being sacked). The West Wing handles it better than most. In part it's the
energy, whether President Jed Bartlet's enthusiasms and motor-mouth (tonight,
it's space, Galileo and 19th-century music) or the long tracking shots as fast-talking
characters deftly handling densely worded dialogue move from rabbit warren to
rabbit warren. And a major part is that very dialogue: literate, pop-culture
savvy, but not afraid to step up into a higher brow, dotted with jokes that
require you to pay attention. It's a television verity that everything matters
equally and this episode reflects that in politics that holds even truer. A
Russian missile explosion, green beans, Iceland's whale hunt and an office crush
compete for attention, both ours and the White House staff. And once again Allison
Janney as the White House press secretary steals the show.
- REVIEW FOR "NOEL"
Date: 12th June, 2001
Publication: The Age
Headline: Stumped For A New Look
Author: Jonathan Green
- In tiptop form is The West Wing (Nine, 10.30pm), in which we achieve a consecutive
plot strand count of six. That's a lot of balls to keep in the air, but the
writers of this televisual epic combine the subplots and shifting time references
with a slippery ease. It's Christmas Eve in Washington and Josh is struggling
through ``nine kinds of pain'' in the lingering aftermath of the shooting that
has left him scarred in mind as well as body. We set the politics aside tonight
in favor of tense psychological drama, as Josh confronts both a counsellor and
the inner demons that are making his life hell. Utterly outstanding.
A tense mind-drama that shows this superb show at its best. Tough times for
deputy White House Chief of Staff Josh Lyman as he attempts to deal with the
ghosts of a bungled assassination attempt.
- REVIEWS FOR "THE LEADERSHIP BREAKFAST"
Date: 19th June, 2001
Publication: The Age
Headline: Meet An Ali With Spirit
Author: Jonathan Green
- The Republican Party has returned to The Hill post midterms enjoying a tidy
majority, and for the first time in his presidency, Josiah Bartlet is facing
tough and potentially lethal opposition. In The West Wing (Nine, 10.30pm) we
are moving to a war footing. (``We is movin to a war footsin.'') The big moment
in tonight's episode is a White House breakfast thrown for members of both parties
and houses. It's a political stunt, a photo opportunity in the minds of most
involved, though Toby wages a lonely campaign to make the most of the opportunity
and talk a little policy. (``Make de mostest of de opportunity and natta a liddle
policy.'') And here we see played out what must be a central dynamic flexing
the innards of modern politics: the tension between those who see the fundamental
purpose of the exercise as sustaining the grip on power, and those who see power
as a means of achieving social ends. (``Those who check powa as a means of achievin
da social end.'') Toby is with the latter camp, and he has a bloody nose coming.
(``E's in massiv aggro.'')
- Date: 18th June, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: TV Previews
Author: Jenny Tabakoff
- The West Wing Nine, 10.30pm
Not as good as we were led to believe, but this American presidential drama
is still devious and entertaining. This week, it's the usual series of backroom
disasters, beginning with a fire alarm and ending with some knickers turning
up in the wrong place. The show has a couple of problems: the way the orchestra
swells patriotically every time the President says something such as, ``There's
a lot more that unites Americans than divides them'', and the fact that backroom
manoeuvring is about as interesting as committee-room minutes
- Date: 19th June, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: White House, Black Humour And A Power Breakfast Leaves Egg On A Lot Of Faces
Author: Robin Oliver
- The West Wing: The Leadership Breakfast 10.30pm, Nine:
Admiration for this series continues undiluted, but it should be said that this
is one of those episodes in which an attempt is made to reintroduce political
complexity often softened to allow the Bartlet Administration to bask in a warm
glow and to mix it with humour, with the result that several untidy incidents
are thrown into the mix and blended to make one hopelessly bad day at Black
Rock.
Plausibility, despite a strong dash of dramatic romanticism and White House
banter, has always been the strength of The West Wing, but now the executive
staff has egg on its face after a string of misjudgments, leaving its Republican
opposition aware that dirty work is still the best political game in town. If
this idealistic White House is the one many Americans might prefer, Aaron Sorkin's
drama deliberately pumps up the fiction by running two years out of sync with
the real political calendar. So the next presidential election is still 22 months
away and this is the start of a year in which the mid-term elections have put
the Republicans in control of both Congress and the Senate, a situation that
existed for the last six years of the Clinton Administration. A bipartisan breakfast
meeting has been called and at this point The West Wing temporarily slips off
the rails with the silly fireplace incident, perhaps for the sole purpose of
allowing one smart throwaway joke as President Bartlet (Martin Sheen) is awakened
in the dead of night. Then there is the curious, perhaps dubious, incident of
Donna's misplaced underwear at a gathering at which a prominent New York Times
columnist was present. I see what this may be getting at at least, I think I
do after replaying the fast-spoken scene four or five times but have taken to
blaming the sound on the preview tape to cover my confusion. The interesting
Ainsley Hayes (Emily Proctor), the Republican lawyer who joined a Democratic
White House staff, now seems to have been banished to her basement office. However,
the search for glamour goes on and we now meet the Republican majority's ambitious
chief of staff, played by Felicity Huffman.
- REVIEW FOR "THE DROP-IN"
Date: 9th July, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: TV PREVIEWS
Author: Matt Buchanan
- The West Wing Nine, 10.30pm
The West Wing is for anyone who has ever wondered how it is the US president
finds time to actually preside over his nation's affairs. With all that striding
across the White House lawn, waving from helicopters and those supremely presidential
addresses, it's a wonder he has time to do anything other than fix his make-up.
Here we see that not only does the president have helpers (phew), but that a
good presidency will come down to how the president manages his helpers and,
just as importantly, how the helpers manage the president. Tonight, everyone
has their hands full. Leo, the chief of staff, is pushing for money to back
the Strategic Defence Initiative, but President Bartlet believes it to be a
folly. He is busy investing new ambassadors. Meanwhile, as Sam Seaborn is getting
pumped up writing a presidential speech about the greenhouse effect, Bartlet
and Toby Ziegler (Seaborn's boss) are planning a drop-in comment that will undermine
its impact. There's more, much more, and throughout it all Bartlet keeps talking,
making asides and managing his people: and all the while they keep talking,
making asides and managing him.
- REVIEWS FOR "BARTLET'S THIRD STATE OF THE UNION"
Date: 17th July, 2001
Publication: The West Australian
Headline: Chillingly Cool
Author: Mark Naglazas
- IF ONLY young men and women could find their role models elsewhere in the culture,
such Nine's dazzling political drama The West Wing (Nine, 10.30pm). Instead
of Mooks and Midriffs, we have men and women of startling intelligence - political
operators who get an almost sexual thrill out of the parry and thrust of political
debate. The smart talk reaches giddy new levels in tonight's episode of The
West Wing in which President Josiah Bartlet gives his third State of the Union
address, a supposedly celebratory event that has a huge wet blanket thrown over
it when five Drug Enforcement Agency operatives are kidnapped in Colombia. While
the talk is as compelling as ever, this especially strong episode is characterised
by a rare dip into the personal, with the wonderful Stockard Channing (as Bartlet's
feisty wife) challenging all the president's men on their commitment to Democrat
ideals. Gosh, I'd love her to do a Hillary and make a run for office.
- Date: 17th July, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: Cool Ways To Make A Zillion Dollars Out Of Teenagers (and Other Pleasures
Of Democracy)
Author: Doug Anderson
- The West Wing 10.30pm, 9: It becomes increasingly apparent that despite being
a fictional character, Jeb Bartlett enjoys far greater credibility than the
inept turkey now floating about the White House affecting a lacklustre impression
of a superpower leader. George Bush presents as an amiable bozo with the kind
of folksy values that endeared the tragically incompetent Cowboy Ron to millions
but with little of that actor's intellectual rigour ... if that's not too wild
a description. In tonight's instalment, the President is beset by nerves as
he prepares to deliver his third State of the Union address an oration the media
is touting as the most important speech of his political career.
- REVIEW FOR "THE WAR AT HOME"
Date: 24th July, 2001
Publication: The West Australian
Headline:Wings Of Emotion
Author: Mark Naglazas
- THE sometimes too dry and cerebral West Wing kicked into emotional high gear
with last week's State of the Union address episode, in which Martin Sheen's
President Josiah Bartlet had to deal with two formidable threats to his power
- Colombian drug dealers and his own wife. The hostilities continue in this
week's show (Nine, 10.45), with Bartlet authorising a special forces team to
rescue five kidnapped drug authority agents. When the operation goes tragically
wrong, Bartlet faces one of the biggest crises of his presidency.
However, dealing with his own feisty wife Abby, played with typical snap, crackle
and pop by the great Stockard Channing, proves even more of a challenge. Abby
is angry that he delivered such a soft-centred and obvious vote-catching address,
indicating that he's broken his promise about running for a second term. Actually,
the whole episode sizzles. Especially gripping is a scene involving Toby Zeigler
(Richard Schiff) and a powerful left-wing leader played by Ed Begley jun., who
refuses to be brought to the heel. Just the episode to shake viewers out of
the post-Big Brother mental malaise.
- REVIEW FOR "ELLIE"
Date: 30th July, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: TV Previews
Author: Stuart O'Connor
- The West Wing Nine, 10.30pm
One of the better episodes of this consistently fine series that gives us a
glimpse into the strange machinations of politics. This week we get a further
peek into the private life of President Jed Bartlet (Martin Sheen), who has
a confrontation with his middle daughter, Ellie (Nina Siemaszko), when she gives
a comment to the press. Ellie has come out in support of Surgeon-General Millicent
Griffith (Mary Kay Place), who hinted in an online chat that marijuana should
be decriminalised against White House policy. Ellie says that her father would
never sack Griffith, which infuriates the President who has always had a strict
rule about keeping his children out of the public eye.
- REVIEW FOR "THE STACKHOUSE FILIBUSTER"
Date: 14th August, 2001
Publication: The Age
Headline: A Presidential Midlife Crisis
Author: Jonathan Green
- "OH no, it's the letterhome plotdriver, a device last employed in M*A*S*H*,
season six, October 1977. Cut to Radar's teddybearstuffed bed, as the lad's
voiceover talks us through recent events at the 4077th as described in a letter
he's writing to the folks: "Well Mom, it all started when Father Mulcahy and
Trapper decided to throw a surprise party for Major Houlihan ...'' And now this
creaking television cliche raises its ugly pen in The West Wing (Nine, 10.30pm),
a sign perhaps of a creeping lassitude among the writing staff. Either that
or the mushrooms are kicking in. CJ and Sam compose emails to their dads, Josh
writes to his mum, and each gets a share of some pretty saccharine firstperson
voiceover action while we flesh their story arcs. Sheeesh."
It's a pretty subpar episode of a show that seems to be battling some sort of
midlife crisis of late. Symptoms: too much character based schmaltz and not
enough politics. Anyway, tonight the gang, Josh in particular, are made to look
smug and heartless by a 78yearold senator so desperate to have something of
deep personal value set in legislation that he keeps his feet for more than
eight hours in a filibuster that has the White House scratching its head. Why
is this guy doing this? What's his game? Donna, of course, works it out in the
end, but I'm sorry, the whole setup is so clunkily obvious that asking us to
believe that the answer to this show's central and driving question would have
evaded the sharpest political minds in the Western world until the dramatically
strategic moment is like, stretching it.
- REVIEW FOR "17 PEOPLE"
Date: 20th August, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: TV Previews
Author: Michael Idato
- The West Wing Nine, 10.30pm
A powerful episode, which explores the ramifications of President Bartlet's
(Martin Sheen) decision not to reveal the fact that he is suffering from multiple
sclerosis. Viewers learnt of his illness several episodes ago and the information
has slowly spread through the White House. After communications director Toby
Ziegler (Richard Schiff) convinces himself the President doesn't intend to run
for re-election, chief of staff Leo McGarry (John Spencer) convinces the Prez
to tell Toby the truth. Needless to say, he's less than impressed, convinced
the public will feel betrayed that they were not allowed to make a choice about
electing a man with a debilitating disease to the White House. However, Bartlet
is unrepentant feeling responsible only to his wife and family. It's a great
episode, distracted a little by sub-plots, but Sheen flexes his acting muscles
beautifully and delivers an impressive performance as a man determined to hang
on to some part of himself, despite his obligations to the American people.
- REVIEW FOR "BAD MOON RISING"
Date: 28th August, 2001
Publication: The West Australian
Headline: Trouble in the White House
Author: Mark Naglazas
- MY ONLY complaint about the otherwise superlative Washington-set series The
West Wing is that it can be a little impersonal, with so much time given over
to politicking that we barely learn anything about the private lives of President
Bartlet or his staff.
However, the personal and the political collided in spectacular fashion in last
week's episode when it was revealed that the president might have defrauded
the American people when he ran for election without alerting them of his multiple
sclerosis. President Bartlet is adamant that he has done nothing illegal. However,
when Toby Ziegler, the communications director and senior political adviser,
learnt about this impeachable offence he was outraged, opening the way for some
of the most wrenching clashes in The West Wing's two-year history. The tension
cranks up even further in tonight's show (Nine, 10.30) when Leo orders the president
to spill the beans to White House counsel Oliver Babish (played with wonderful
gusto by Emmy nominee Oliver Platt), a straight-shooting bear of a man who,
over the next few weeks, upsets everyone in sight, including Bartlet himself,
in assembling information to defend Bartlet. This is the best series of episodes
yet in a justly lauded drama and the perfect time for late-comers to cast their
vote.
- REVIEW FOR "18TH & POTOMAC"
Date: 18th September, 2001
Publication: The West Australian
Headline: Bush fades to West Wing.
Author: Mark Naglazas
- "AFTER watching George W. Bush's hollow, uninspiring performance in the wake
of the terrorist attacks on New York and Washington, I bet a fair proportion
of Americans would have been wishing that The West Wing's Martin Sheen was their
president. In stark contrast to Bush, who looks like he stumbled into the world's
most important job by mistake, Sheen's Josiah Bartlet strode through the first
two seasons of this justly acclaimed political drama like a Kennedy-esque colossus
- empathising with the meek, shouting down his enemies and steering the nation
through crises."
Of course, Bartlet is a highly idealised figure, as is the rest of the cast
of The West Wing which features what must be the most dazzlingly intelligent,
wondrously articulate lot ever to appear on a mainstream television drama. Astutely,
creator and chief writer Aaron Sorkin has, in recent episodes, shown us that
Bartlet is a mere mortal after all with the shocking revelation that he may
have committed an impeachable offence by lying to the American people about
his multiple sclerosis. The pressure mounts in tonight's penultimate episode
(Nine, 10.30) as the shell-shocked staff struggle to work out the best way to
inform the nation, a problem compounded by a crisis brewing in Haiti. Series
three of The West Wing has yet to begin in the United States. Like much of the
autumn season of US television it was put on hold by the appalling events in
New York. When it does return, it will be interesting to see how The West Wing,
which feeds off current political reality, will respond not simply to the attack
on the World Trade Centre and the Pentagon but what is shaping up to be a prolonged
war of retribution. Sadly, this is a great show that may be rendered irrelevant
by an unthinkable reality. Or it may respond and become something quite special,
providing education and an uplift for the American people.
- REVIEW FOR "TWO CATHEDRALS"
Date: 29th September, 2001
Publication: Sydney Morning Herald
Headline: Stars Didn't Quite Earn Their Stripes
Author: Ruth Ritchie
- Music is never a problem in The West Wing (Nine, Tuesday) although President
Bartlet's big episode didn't play very well in my house. Real life drama has
certainly made Aaron Sorkin's usually sharp fiction seem soft. A siege in the
embassy in Haiti, a press conference in the East Room, the funeral of his long-time
secretary Mrs Landingham these would normally make for a big season finale but,
in comparison with the real world, we got an episode of The Waltons. With or
without the global conflict, the episode simply drowned in bathos (that's the
stuff Americans put on their cereal while we stick to milk). So much sentiment,
so much navel-gazing, so much water in the wind-and-rain machine. I rather lost
respect for Jed Bartlet this week as he decided to workshop a few of his own
childhood issues by hanging out in the Oval Office for four more years. Not
very responsible, Jed. Smoking in the cathedral while he told God where to go.
On paper that must have looked brave. It played like melodrama. Probably worked
like a wheel with an audience who gives George Bush a 90 per cent approval rating.
|